Should extinct animals be brought back?

[Bakerboy 4,221]

38 minutes ago, Pewit said:

Further reading clarifies what I thought, due to the degradation of DNA, scientists will never be able to recreate exact  replicas of extinct animals.

To me if it looks like a Mammoth walks like a Mammoth sounds like a Mammoth its a fckn Mammoth

[Pewit 969]

2 minutes ago, Bakerboy said:

To me if it looks like a Mammoth walks like a Mammoth sounds like a Mammoth its a fckn Mammoth

It'll be just a hairy elephant.

[eastcoast 4,006]

Re-creating the old stamp working type Sealyham terrier would be an interesting project. A skilled breeder could have the newly created type breeding true in 4 generations. 

[Pewit 969]

6 minutes ago, eastcoast said:

Re-creating the old stamp working type Sealyham terrier would be an interesting project. A skilled breeder could have the newly created type breeding true in 4 generations. 

You could do that through proper work & selection.

[Lenmcharristar 9,587]

1 hour ago, Pewit said:

Further reading clarifies what I thought, due to the degradation of DNA, scientists will never be able to recreate exact  replicas of extinct animals.

True at this stage, but science always making breakthroughs, could end up with o e yet, science always contradicts itself

[chartpolski 22,405]

8 minutes ago, eastcoast said:

Re-creating the old stamp working type Sealyham terrier would be an interesting project. A skilled breeder could have the newly created type breeding true in 4 generations. 

What do you think of the Sporting Lucas terrier ?

Used to see a few at shows years ago, don’t see them now.

Cheers.

[Pewit 969]

6 minutes ago, Lenmcharristar said:

True at this stage, but science always making breakthroughs, could end up with o e yet, science always contradicts itself

Who knows but you as far as we know you can't replicate what is lost, and sometimes those lost links are quite important. 

[eastcoast 4,006]

13 minutes ago, chartpolski said:

What do you think of the Sporting Lucas terrier ?

Used to see a few at shows years ago, don’t see them now.

Cheers.

Some genuine people got on board as far as I am aware but don't think progressed from a working point of view. See the occasional litter advertised on sites such as Pets4Homes, freakish looking things for £1000+ money. I was taking the piss, D B Plummer made the claim years ago as to how easy it would be to re-create the Sealyham. He maybe could have done, a very clever man by all accounts, but didn't. 

[Bakerboy 4,221]

36 minutes ago, eastcoast said:

Re-creating the old stamp working type Sealyham terrier would be an interesting project. A skilled breeder could have the newly created type breeding true in 4 generations. 

You sound like DBP

[shaaark 10,625]

On 25/07/2024 at 20:08, dai dogs said:

I remember going to Cardiff museum on school trip seeing a taxidermy Tasmanian Tiger blew my mind 

Been to Cardiff museum many times, and that giant turtle is an absolute beast.

[Lenmcharristar 9,587]

50 minutes ago, Pewit said:

Who knows but you as far as we know you can't replicate what is lost, and sometimes those lost links are quite important. 

Yes i know that, only God has the correct codes, where in the case of thylacine they can check multiple specimens and get a better match to the correct codes, the mammoth they hope to use the asian elephant but how close they get who knows? The dire wolf bones where found in the boneyard aswell as north american lions, how well preserved the dna is though is anyones guess, but 1 thing they were discussing was the mammoth meat they ate at bbqs,  there must be some well preserved carcasses around

[greg64 2,710]

23 hours ago, Lenmcharristar said:

With fish, id like to see the arctic charr restocked i to rivers all throughout the uk and ireland, they were here in abundance now extinct except for a few pockets of ancient lakes

there's some arctic char also known as torgoch in   llyn Padarn in north Wales near Llanberis 

[Lenmcharristar 9,587]

2 minutes ago, greg64 said:

there's some arctic char also known as torgoch in   llyn Padarn in north Wales near Llanberis 

You ever catch any?

[greg64 2,710]

Just now, Lenmcharristar said:

You ever catch any?

no never fished for them

[Lenmcharristar 9,587]

Just now, greg64 said:

no never fished for them

Me either but id love to give it a go