Random Question

[atilla the hunter 60]

Here's something I been thinking about. While on a 20 hour road trip totaly hypothetical before I get slaughterd lol 2 litter brothers peas in a pod dog 1 is a top dog gives its all evry time out and is lost, , dog 2 dosent make the grade comes away spewes what ever u want to call it but is lucky and still alive , now u have a top bitch same way bread the better dog is gone the second dog is shite the brothers share the exactly the same blood whuld the chances of producing workers be the same from each dog being the same blood. Or what whuld the good dog have to offer that the spewer dident? what's the difference if the blood is exactly the same

 

[Outlaw Pete 2,224]

F**kin Lovely little Thinker! I, too, shall be interested in theories on this one!

[forest of dean redneck 11,686]

Are you saying the bitch shares same ancestory as the 2 dogs?

If so for me no,I would be looking for a different sire ,one that gives 100 percent,at his job.

To be honest I would be doubtful about using the jacker anyway,some pups don't make the grade with both parents 100 percent workers ,let alone if ones not pulling its weight.

[atilla the hunter 60]

The bitch whuld be half sister to the 2 brothers hypotheticly speaking

[forest of dean redneck 11,686]

Then a no from me,find different stud.

[atilla the hunter 60]

So forest you whuld rather use a compleat stranger to your line rather than use a jacker of the same blood?

[marshman 7,758]

Lol not a thinker for me as the answer is no end of !

[atilla the hunter 60]

What are your reasons marshman If the blood is exactly the same what whuld the good dog pass on what the jacker whuldent?

[Hot Meat 3,109]

What are your reasons marshman If the blood is exactly the same what whuld the good dog pass on what the jacker whuldent?

 

Peace of mind

[marshman 7,758]

What are your reasons marshman If the blood is exactly the same what whuld the good dog pass on what the jacker whuldent?

well what your hoping is that the good dog would pass on the "minerals" that he's lesser cur of a brother doesn't have. So if the good dog wasn't about and had died, I would look for a relative ie grandfather uncle or half brother of course one that grafts and use that.

[atilla the hunter 60]

I agree hot meat but you can not use a dead dog no matter how good it was ,,, so whuld you use a total out cross what might not gel or take your chance on a jacker from a predictable line what has the exact same blood as the good dog what is fertiliser,,, basicly what I am getting at is what's the difference if the blood is exactly the same

[Hot Meat 3,109]

It's been proven it's not always the best worker/performer that's the best producer when it comes to breeding, if you found yourself in the situation you have thought up, then you have a choice to make, some will some won't. But the first question I'd ask meself is could I have faith in dogs bred out a jacker???

[danw 1,748]

It's been proven it's not always the best worker/performer that's the best producer when it comes to breeding, if you found yourself in the situation you have thought up, then you have a choice to make, some will some won't. But the first question I'd ask meself is could I have faith in dogs bred out a jacker???

and there is the answer

 

what if a litter of 6 throws one star but 5 potlickers would you still breed from the one good one

[atilla the hunter 60]

Good answer hotmeat :-) if you was in the situation whuld you go for a

Unrelated outcross or use the jacker what's litter brother and sisters were bang on apart from the un culled brother. Let's say these dogs are orphans no relations to hand to rule out the obvious answers

[jeemes 4,485]

They wont share the same gene combinations