04fox8 168 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Well as usual I am the one with a different opinion. What I see in people like Brady are people who are seriously mentally ill, what he has done can be considered evil but the fact is he isn't all there and doesn't feel any remorse or know how to. Is it fair to torture someone who is mentally ill? If someone had a brain tumor that damaged the part of their brain that kept them inline, would you then label as a monster and bury them alive? He won't ever get better, he wants to die so let the f****r die...no good can come from dragging out his existence. He is wrong in the head, of that there is no doubt....But is that really a 'fact'?? What tests / experiment have they done to prove / disprove his mental status..? Can they really rely on their findings? Well the fact he is kept in a mental institution instead of a prison was the giveaway for me, I don't know the exact tests though you got me there. I'm fairly sure any one of us could make a good attempt at pretending to be 'mentally unstable'. You said 'the fact is'......But Can we be sure? I think he's just a twisted b**tard! No fancy names / excuses. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Ratreeper 441 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Well as usual I am the one with a different opinion. What I see in people like Brady are people who are seriously mentally ill, what he has done can be considered evil but the fact is he isn't all there and doesn't feel any remorse or know how to. Is it fair to torture someone who is mentally ill? If someone had a brain tumor that damaged the part of their brain that kept them inline, would you then label as a monster and bury them alive? He won't ever get better, he wants to die so let the f****r die...no good can come from dragging out his existence. The same could be said for any kiddy fiddler or child murderer, what they do is that far from normal, acceptable human behaviour it can only be put down to them not being wired up right in the head.. Should be pity them all rather than despise them? I didn't say he should be pitied, I am saying people like that are never going to learn anything or be cured and dragging out their lives benefits no-one. So understanding WHY he would do such things is different to trying to even the score by torturing someone who is mentally ill. Just ask yourself, if you swapped places with Brady and had his mind and upbringing you have to admit that you would have performed the same actions, it is 100% guaranteed that if you were him you would have done the same..There is no free will involved, let the f****r end his life. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Ratreeper 441 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Well as usual I am the one with a different opinion. What I see in people like Brady are people who are seriously mentally ill, what he has done can be considered evil but the fact is he isn't all there and doesn't feel any remorse or know how to. Is it fair to torture someone who is mentally ill? If someone had a brain tumor that damaged the part of their brain that kept them inline, would you then label as a monster and bury them alive? He won't ever get better, he wants to die so let the f****r die...no good can come from dragging out his existence. He is wrong in the head, of that there is no doubt....But is that really a 'fact'?? What tests / experiment have they done to prove / disprove his mental status..? Can they really rely on their findings? Well the fact he is kept in a mental institution instead of a prison was the giveaway for me, I don't know the exact tests though you got me there. I'm fairly sure any one of us could make a good attempt at pretending to be 'mentally unstable'. You said 'the fact is'......But Can we be sure? I think he's just a twisted b**tard! No fancy names / excuses. True someone could pretend, but I suppose it just depends on how much you trust modern psychology to be able to differentiate between a fraud and a real nutter. Anyway i don't want to give the impression I feel bad for the guy, I just don't advocate torturing someone who is mentally ill because anyone could have a condition and do things they can't control and to then torture them seems immoral, the point of being a good person is to be better than those you convict. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
04fox8 168 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Well as usual I am the one with a different opinion. What I see in people like Brady are people who are seriously mentally ill, what he has done can be considered evil but the fact is he isn't all there and doesn't feel any remorse or know how to. Is it fair to torture someone who is mentally ill? If someone had a brain tumor that damaged the part of their brain that kept them inline, would you then label as a monster and bury them alive? He won't ever get better, he wants to die so let the f****r die...no good can come from dragging out his existence. He is wrong in the head, of that there is no doubt....But is that really a 'fact'?? What tests / experiment have they done to prove / disprove his mental status..? Can they really rely on their findings? Well the fact he is kept in a mental institution instead of a prison was the giveaway for me, I don't know the exact tests though you got me there. I'm fairly sure any one of us could make a good attempt at pretending to be 'mentally unstable'. You said 'the fact is'......But Can we be sure? I think he's just a twisted b**tard! No fancy names / excuses. True someone could pretend, but I suppose it just depends on how much you trust modern psychology to be able to differentiate between a fraud and a real nutter. Anyway i don't want to give the impression I feel bad for the guy, I just don't advocate torturing someone who is mentally ill because anyone could have a condition and do things they can't control and to then torture them seems immoral, the point of being a good person is to be better than those you convict. Tell my wife that after a good night out.. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
sikastag_1 689 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Well as usual I am the one with a different opinion. What I see in people like Brady are people who are seriously mentally ill, what he has done can be considered evil but the fact is he isn't all there and doesn't feel any remorse or know how to. Is it fair to torture someone who is mentally ill? If someone had a brain tumor that damaged the part of their brain that kept them inline, would you then label as a monster and bury them alive? He won't ever get better, he wants to die so let the f****r die...no good can come from dragging out his existence. Listen mate don't take this the wrong way but its because of opinions like that that these fuckers are living the way they are, I remember watching on tv about a guy who handed himself in because he was ill and was going to harm somebody so fair play to him, this is scum were talking about here, eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Outlaw Pete 2,224 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Has nobody actually taken the time to read that article, before going off with their 'fact' based opinions? A raft of the best shrinks the country's got to offer have been feeling his bumps for years and years. Conclusion? There's f**k all wrong with his head. He's simply a staggeringly arrogant, completely self obsessed and cold hearted bastard. Simple as. No f**king 'illness'. He's just a c**t. No one ever claims Hitler was off his trolley. So; Would I condone, " Wake up, Ian. Here comes the wet towel, again! " ? F**king right I would! 5 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
walshie 2,804 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 This talk about whether someone is "sane" or not is bollocks. Obviously no-one SANE would torture and kill a load of kids. The bottom line is he murdered innocent children regardless of his mental state so should pay for those crimes. 3 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
scothunter 12,609 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 lets be realistic here lads,the only c**ts who want him alive are the psycolgists and do gooders in those places.tbh best place for those c**ts.there about as weird as the folk they lock up. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
dare 1,103 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 Bit of random info but a doctor that my dad regular works with carried out the post mortem for Myra Hindley. My dad mentioned that he had read online about her death being fake. The doctor swore on his kids life she is though. I say keep the b*****d alive if he wants to be allowed to kill himself. Prehaps in his sick head it's him having some control again. His victims had no choice and any animal that can do what he done will never be sane in my books. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
dedger 16 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 What about the people with motoneurone disease? These people have been begging to end their lives for years but our government won't let them, so why create another rule for this sick b&st**d. Let him live against his wishes. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
scothunter 12,609 Posted June 18, 2013 Report Share Posted June 18, 2013 What about the people with motoneurone disease? These people have been begging to end their lives for years but our government won't let them, so why create another rule for this sick b&st**d. Let him live against his wishes. thats a very fair point,and a view i hadnt considered Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.