minshaws are different to collie cross

[Guest Moscow]

Who cares this crap is boring and repetative now.

[weasle 1,119]

They're all just lurchers.............my pup is 8 months now, I can see a lot of traits in her that are collie traits but also others you don't usually associate with a collie x. This pup seems more full on than any collie x I've owned but as she's maturing she's becoming much more tractable, she'll not be just a lamping dog I'll be ferreting etc with her.

 

If I'm asked what x she is I usually reply that she's a "Lurcher"...........names and monikers don't make a dog, collie x's, Minshaws, collie curs call them what you like they'll only be as good as you make them, put the work in and enjoy the rewards.

Fairplay to you,You always seem realistic,Unlike some that seem to think they have some kind of golden chalice,And need to prove there selves to every one.Hope the dog comes good for ya.

[I'm...a ...ginger 11]

what is in a minshaw? how can you tell its a minshaw?

[Hitcher 297]

shit an i thought they were bull x ,,,,,,400 pages thats me sorted for tonight

[johnny boy68 11,726]

They're all just lurchers.............my pup is 8 months now, I can see a lot of traits in her that are collie traits but also others you don't usually associate with a collie x. This pup seems more full on than any collie x I've owned but as she's maturing she's becoming much more tractable, she'll not be just a lamping dog I'll be ferreting etc with her.

 

If I'm asked what x she is I usually reply that she's a "Lurcher"...........names and monikers don't make a dog, collie x's, Minshaws, collie curs call them what you like they'll only be as good as you make them, put the work in and enjoy the rewards.

Fairplay to you,You always seem realistic,Unlike some that seem to think they have some kind of golden chalice,And need to prove there selves to every one.Hope the dog comes good for ya.

Cheers mate, always best to keep it real !

[bird 9,944]

i think the main difference is that with collie / greyhound x's you get much more variety of type and attitude ie smaller collie types, big racy etc and ones that want to herd, some with the guard mentality some with a strong hunting instinct etc. it seems the minhsaw type has been bred from the best of every generation where the best most desired traits have been strengthened, no doubt theres been bits of other things along the way with bull beddy and saluki in there. also how many collie x guys genuinely put as much gear in front of their dogs? these guy's have been out doing it for generations their not put off by a bit of cold or bad weather and the dogs are truly tested. i'm a collie cross fan but not blinded enough to think that every collie x pup makes the grade. just my thoughts guys

 

very true with the differnce in colliexs , as you say ive have hard temps, and some soft. Prob comes down to what collie as been used as well,? ive had 3 all been differnt temps, 1 was nervy, 2 Blaze who ive spoke before of was hard fecker loved anything that bite back lol ok on rabbits, 3rd Bryn best rabbit dog of the 3, softer temp than Blaze but would fire in when i had Tod on anything.! The minshaws type have been bred for hardnights lamping over the years, so prob you get better stamina, but most of my colliexs have had good stamina, as long as they fill the bag it dont matter what x it is.

[weasle 1,119]

And most average dogs are able to fill the bag,how big the bag depends on how fit and how much chance they get,as well as how much game is in the area.But lads that no better read some of the bs on here and think there poor mut is no good cause he aint got the fancy name.

[Tiny 7 1,694]

People worry too much about other people dogs, What they call them , What they do with them or where they work them......

 

FFS people the seasons not too far away enjoy it no matter what your mutts are, If your happy with them then thats all that matters there ALL just lurchers at the end of the day

[Guest Moscow]

How much collie does a dog have in it before its called a collie x? is there just collie and greyhound in the mix? my dogs have as much if not more bull in as collie are they bull x, collie x or lurchers. TBH I dont care what anyone calls them as long as they suite me thats all that counts.

[Giro 2,648]

One thing for sure...

 

If I wanted a Minshaw type I would becareful were I sourced it from..

 

Last Litter I seen advertised,what a joke they never even had the breeding right, sales ploy .

 

I prefer Moscows Bull crosses,even if they cant do it on the Big flat wheat feilds recon they could do it in stonewalled feilds

[Tiny 7 1,694]

How much collie does a dog have in it before its called a collie x? is there just collie and greyhound in the mix? my dogs have as much if not more bull in as collie are they bull x, collie x or lurchers. TBH I dont care what anyone calls them as long as they suite me thats all that counts.

 

Well thats it Moscow..

 

Iv got a bitch here Shes a Sal/Bull/GhXFoxhound X Beddy/Whip/Weaten/Gh What do i call her...? A Sal X's, Bull X's, FoxhoundX's BeddyX's, Weaten X's, Whip/Gh or just a fcuk up....?

 

Shes just a Lurcher/Lurcher to me

[Guest Moscow]

I prefer Moscows Bull crosses,even if they cant do it on the Big flat wheat feilds recon they could do it in stonewalled feilds

 

My "fat bull crosses" are to slow to catch on any type of fields

[Giro 2,648]

They would do ok were I go

 

I lamp in feilds the size of phone boxs let whin keep than big land save my legs :laugh:

[Guest Moscow]

They would do ok were I go

 

I lamp in feilds the size of phone boxs let whin keep than big land save my legs :laugh:

 

They do ok on any type of land mate

[Millet 4,497]

As i have said before Minshaw Lurcher type's have Grey/Saluki/Deerhound/Collie/Beddie and god know's what else in there make up so how can they be classed as Collie crosses.. .. a Collie x grey on the other hand is what it say's on the tin.