minshaws are different to collie cross

[minshaw man 111]

iv owened numerous collie cross and i own 2 minshaws now i onestly think ther temperament and the style that they run is different to any collie crosses in every way just wondering any other minshaw lads that think the same as my minshaws run in lyk a diiferent style to any other collies xs iv had and seen

[bigdaz 688]

So are you saying minshaws are collie crosses but different from other collie crosses.

[minshaw man 111]

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:37, bigdaz said:

So are you saying minshaws are collie crosses but different from other collie crosses.

different alltogetha

[Ideation 8,216]

 

Aye, a million miles different . . . . . . .

 

Naaaaw, to be honest, the one i've seen a lot recently, has a lot of collie traits.

 

Which isn't that surprising, considering that she is pretty much half collie.

[bigdaz 688]

I'm confused, I thought the people who had them said they weren't collie crosses.

[chartpolski 25,481]

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:39, minshaw man said:

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:37, bigdaz said:

So are you saying minshaws are collie crosses but different from other collie crosses.

different alltogetha

 

But surely "Minshaws" are mainly Collie and Greyhound, with a wee bit of Beddy and Deerhound way back in the line, so could quite reasonably be described as Collie Crosses ? Or have I wasted my time reading almost 400 pages on the "Minshaw" thread ?

 

Cheers.

[ferret features 289]

they must be late starters there was 1 on the other thread still chasing tennis ball round a yard it was about a year old.

[minshaw man 111]

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:53, chartpolski said:

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:39, minshaw man said:

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:37, bigdaz said:

So are you saying minshaws are collie crosses but different from other collie crosses.

different alltogetha

 

But surely "Minshaws" are mainly Collie and Greyhound, with a wee bit of Beddy and Deerhound way back in the line, so could quite reasonably be described as Collie Crosses ? Or have I wasted my time reading almost 400 pages on the "Minshaw" thread ?

 

Cheers.

no myne are totelly different style of runners to all collies ive owened and seen

[iWorkChihuahuas 52]

no wonder theyre different, theyre minshaws.... not collie x

[hedz31 1,308]

I can see this 1 going round in circle's

[Rabbiting man 1,192]

Who gives a shit they both lurcher types anyway.

[Guest born to run1083]

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:53, chartpolski said:

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:39, minshaw man said:

  On 29/07/2012 at 20:37, bigdaz said:

So are you saying minshaws are collie crosses but different from other collie crosses.

different alltogetha

 

But surely "Minshaws" are mainly Collie and Greyhound, with a wee bit of Beddy and Deerhound way back in the line, so could quite reasonably be described as Collie Crosses ? Or have I wasted my time reading almost 400 pages on the "Minshaw" thread ?

 

Cheers.

I had a lengthy debate on this on the minshaw thread.

Millet will love this thread

[bird 10,013]

  On 29/07/2012 at 21:09, iWorkChihuahuas said:

no wonder theyre different, theyre minshaws.... not collie x

 

well i may wrong here, but from what ive read (minshaw) type lurcher was bred as a out and out lamping dog. Where as most colliexs are day+ night time dogs. My dog Bryn as had in the past some very good bags(20-30) rabbits in the lamp, last time ferreting marked 25 and got fair vew birds in the day. So i reckon they vast differnce in the two xs, unless the minshaw type is being used as the above.

[Guest born to run1083]

Ray altho there good points but if a collie x was used as a gun dog retriever would that mean its no longer a collie x. Regardless of what a type does I've always thought it still carried the same pre fix

[poacher3161 1,766]

Its because the other breeds in them will still be makeing the difference between them and just collie x grey or grews any body whos had collie crosses and collie lurchers crossed to other type lurchers will understand wat your on about.