Catcher 1 639 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 you only have to read the posts in this thread to see the maj dont want it the answer to your question lies in the posts.i agree you are entitled to you say.however i would say to you that when the referendum comes and its founded that the vast maj of scots dont want a break in the union,would you agree that that should be the end of it?also statements like "TRUE SCOTS" is just ridiculous.going by that you must think that the majority of scottish people are not true scots!i suspect you are letting by gone days and history from a time thats so far in the past is clouding your judgement.the troubles in ireland should have no place in your quest for an independent scotland.you do not hide the fact of your disgust and hatred towards the english rule in ireland and i suspect you are comparing that to scotland.which in all fairness really have nothing to do with each other. Think you need to read the post again.Only person makeing ridiculous statement,s is yourself. hows that mate?tell me what i said thats ridiculous please. Mate its simple even for you.Most of what you said had nothing to do with my thread.You seem to make things up as you go along. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
scothunter 12,609 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 you only have to read the posts in this thread to see the maj dont want it the answer to your question lies in the posts.i agree you are entitled to you say.however i would say to you that when the referendum comes and its founded that the vast maj of scots dont want a break in the union,would you agree that that should be the end of it?also statements like "TRUE SCOTS" is just ridiculous.going by that you must think that the majority of scottish people are not true scots!i suspect you are letting by gone days and history from a time thats so far in the past is clouding your judgement.the troubles in ireland should have no place in your quest for an independent scotland.you do not hide the fact of your disgust and hatred towards the english rule in ireland and i suspect you are comparing that to scotland.which in all fairness really have nothing to do with each other. Think you need to read the post again.Only person makeing ridiculous statement,s is yourself. hows that mate?tell me what i said thats ridiculous please. Mate its simple even for you.Most of what you said had nothing to do with my thread.You seem to make things up as you go along. see thats you at your best catcher.you post a statement and when its answered you come back with one line answers.and do not explain yourself. let me break it down so even you will understand it. you asked why are some scots against it.i said you only need to read the post in this thread to get your answer.you then came out with the true scots line.so lets break that down for you now.to date the vast majority of scottish people dont want a break in the union,so therefore you are saying that most scottish people living in scotland are not true scots?maybe it was just conjecture on my part by saying you may compare ireland to scotland,but going by your comments in past threads and that you readily were quick to mention bloody sunday whenever you could you can see why i would make that comparrison.if im wrong on that asoect then i apologise for the latter part of my post. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Catcher 1 639 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 you only have to read the posts in this thread to see the maj dont want it the answer to your question lies in the posts.i agree you are entitled to you say.however i would say to you that when the referendum comes and its founded that the vast maj of scots dont want a break in the union,would you agree that that should be the end of it?also statements like "TRUE SCOTS" is just ridiculous.going by that you must think that the majority of scottish people are not true scots!i suspect you are letting by gone days and history from a time thats so far in the past is clouding your judgement.the troubles in ireland should have no place in your quest for an independent scotland.you do not hide the fact of your disgust and hatred towards the english rule in ireland and i suspect you are comparing that to scotland.which in all fairness really have nothing to do with each other. Think you need to read the post again.Only person makeing ridiculous statement,s is yourself. hows that mate?tell me what i said thats ridiculous please. Mate its simple even for you.Most of what you said had nothing to do with my thread.You seem to make things up as you go along. see thats you at your best catcher.you post a statement and when its answered you come back with one line answers.and do not explain yourself. let me break it down so even you will understand it. you asked why are some scots against it.i said you only need to read the post in this thread to get your answer.you then came out with the true scots line.so lets break that down for you now.to date the vast majority of scottish people dont want a break in the union,so therefore you are saying that most scottish people living in scotland are not true scots?maybe it was just conjecture on my part by saying you may compare ireland to scotland,but going by your comments in past threads and that you readily were quick to mention bloody sunday whenever you could you can see why i would make that comparrison.if im wrong on that asoect then i apologise for the latter part of my post. You come on here saying.Things like Being a true Scot is ridiculous.And my mind is clouding by history.Then go on about the past troubles in Ireland.Cloud,s are only in your head.Dont bring up thing,s i dident say then ask me to explaine.Anyway my day off.the suns coming out and i have dog,s to walk. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
scothunter 12,609 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 you only have to read the posts in this thread to see the maj dont want it the answer to your question lies in the posts.i agree you are entitled to you say.however i would say to you that when the referendum comes and its founded that the vast maj of scots dont want a break in the union,would you agree that that should be the end of it?also statements like "TRUE SCOTS" is just ridiculous.going by that you must think that the majority of scottish people are not true scots!i suspect you are letting by gone days and history from a time thats so far in the past is clouding your judgement.the troubles in ireland should have no place in your quest for an independent scotland.you do not hide the fact of your disgust and hatred towards the english rule in ireland and i suspect you are comparing that to scotland.which in all fairness really have nothing to do with each other. Think you need to read the post again.Only person makeing ridiculous statement,s is yourself. hows that mate?tell me what i said thats ridiculous please. Mate its simple even for you.Most of what you said had nothing to do with my thread.You seem to make things up as you go along. see thats you at your best catcher.you post a statement and when its answered you come back with one line answers.and do not explain yourself. let me break it down so even you will understand it. you asked why are some scots against it.i said you only need to read the post in this thread to get your answer.you then came out with the true scots line.so lets break that down for you now.to date the vast majority of scottish people dont want a break in the union,so therefore you are saying that most scottish people living in scotland are not true scots?maybe it was just conjecture on my part by saying you may compare ireland to scotland,but going by your comments in past threads and that you readily were quick to mention bloody sunday whenever you could you can see why i would make that comparrison.if im wrong on that asoect then i apologise for the latter part of my post. You come on here saying.Things like Being a true Scot is ridiculous.And my mind is clouding by history.Then go on about the past troubles in Ireland.Cloud,s are only in your head.Dont bring up thing,s i dident say then ask me to explaine.Anyway my day off.the suns coming out and i have dog,s to walk. lol you brought up the true scots quote.anyway to early in the morning for this.enjoy your walk Quote Link to post Share on other sites
WILF 46,834 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 As for taxes dont ask the question.If you cant answer it yourself. Catcher mate, I reckon I could take a handy guess and say the numbers wouldnt stack up and you would loose a lot of the perks (for want of a better word) that you currently enjoy + you would be getting taxed through the nose OR You would need to swell the population so much by importing immigrant to get extra tax revenue OR You would need to run to the EU I think your culture up there is one of the strongest on these isles, certianly stronger than England...... Quote Link to post Share on other sites
f mac 40 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 i cant understand any of the replies put forward by both camps history clearly show britain has nothing to offer .thats why we invaded india ,south africa ,west indies,east indies,chinas opium shame ,afganistan twice,the slave trade ,wars with france,spain,ect the only thing that happened was the rich got richer and lords and manors were born leaving the working man in same place he started with sfa .so we just carry on moaning about the price of shit and trying too make a buck regardless of nationality .rant over please dont vote it just encourages people to become mps Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Catcher 1 639 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 As for taxes dont ask the question.If you cant answer it yourself. Catcher mate, I reckon I could take a handy guess and say the numbers wouldnt stack up and you would loose a lot of the perks (for want of a better word) that you currently enjoy + you would be getting taxed through the nose OR You would need to swell the population so much by importing immigrant to get extra tax revenue OR You would need to run to the EU I think your culture up there is one of the strongest on these isles, certianly stronger than England...... Hi WILF.As you say its only a handy guess.Most politician,s can number crunch to make any deal look good.For me it not about that.I class myself as a true Scotsman( A few have said they are no sutch thing.Maybe not for some) who would love to see Scotland independent.As i think we can go it alone. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
fellman 116 Posted May 12, 2011 Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 ok i will vote with you tom IF you agree to compulsory repatriation of all scots .AND the rebuilding and strenghening of hadriens wall.........with lets say a bottle of single malt per grown man sent down over the border as a thank you Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Foxgun Tom 75 Posted May 12, 2011 Author Report Share Posted May 12, 2011 ok i will vote with you tom IF you agree to compulsory repatriation of all scots .AND the rebuilding and strenghening of hadriens wall.........with lets say a bottle of single malt per grown man sent down over the border as a thank you I'd share a bottle of the finest Malt with you anytime, Buddy! Its a pity all the building materials for Hadrian's Wall came from BQ in Newcastle thats why its falling to bits Tom Quote Link to post Share on other sites
fellman 116 Posted May 13, 2011 Report Share Posted May 13, 2011 Look up a song by The Proclaimers .....called "cap in hand" good song still think scotland would be f****d without the english £££££££££££££££££££££ Quote Link to post Share on other sites
scothunter 12,609 Posted May 13, 2011 Report Share Posted May 13, 2011 Look up a song by The Proclaimers .....called "cap in hand" good song still think scotland would be f****d without the english £££££££££££££££££££££ ok lol Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.