The Shadow 10 Posted October 10, 2009 Author Report Share Posted October 10, 2009 I'm sure there was someone working a poodle x a few yrs back be interesting to hear from anyone that knows about or has experience of this x. Quote Link to post
matt32 44 Posted October 10, 2009 Report Share Posted October 10, 2009 i think its wrong typp ratcher is using the fact he writes fot the cmw to dupe newcomers to the sport i believe hes trying to start atrend like the labradoodle 350 for alurcher poodle cross come on it seems like hes trying to corner the market or create one i bet the poodle has never worked and you cant realy on a dogs genes from the past you only find out a dogs strenghts and weaknesses by working it i have lost all respect for the man hes using the cmw to sell his dogs hoping people read his articles and think he knows what hes on about hes a money grabbing fool Quote Link to post
cocker 2,654 Posted October 10, 2009 Report Share Posted October 10, 2009 what are they going to do, that the tried and tested crosses that we already have, cant do???????????? and how come there so expensive??? i think some people are just trying to breed the most rediculous crosses Quote Link to post
undisputed 1,664 Posted October 10, 2009 Report Share Posted October 10, 2009 what are they going to do, that the tried and tested crosses that we already have, cant do???????????? and how come there so expensive??? i think some people are just trying to breed the most rediculous crosses If everyone had that attitude we'd only have collie x's Quote Link to post
cocker 2,654 Posted October 10, 2009 Report Share Posted October 10, 2009 what are they going to do, that the tried and tested crosses that we already have, cant do???????????? and how come there so expensive??? i think some people are just trying to breed the most rediculous crosses If everyone had that attitude we'd only have collie x's "no we wouldnt" Quote Link to post
undisputed 1,664 Posted October 10, 2009 Report Share Posted October 10, 2009 what are they going to do, that the tried and tested crosses that we already have, cant do???????????? and how come there so expensive??? i think some people are just trying to breed the most rediculous crosses If everyone had that attitude we'd only have collie x's "no we wouldnt" Would so! Quote Link to post
dark snipe 0 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 If these pups have 1/8 poodle in then he is breeding lurcher x lurcher, not poodle x lurcher. question is are they worker x worker? Quote Link to post
neil cooney 10,416 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 He'll probably sell all these pups because the world is full of fools who are easily parted with their money. These pups will probably look the part when adult but think about it ? Would they be good for any thing else other than looks? Why do we cross a certain breed over a greyhound in the first place? The greyhound gives us speed and thats all. The other breed must give us the desire to hunt and that "never say die" gameness that we need in a working lurcher. Will a poodle give us that? Don't fool yourself and say "yes". Was it Typp Ratcher a while back that said his pointers could course as well as a lurcher or greyhound? Says it all really. It's a pity crosses like this are tried as I'm lead to believe the rescue societies are full of lurchers. And then you've got lads who breed out of good tried and tested dogs and bitches and can't sell the pups. Quote Link to post
lietome 138 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 Saw this add in the CMW 7/8Grey x Poodle for sale Typp Ratcher. What are folks views on this x is a gimmick or a genuine attempt to introduce what was an old hunting type back into the gene pool. Constructive comments no sniping just for the hell of it. What will this x bring to the Lurcher world?i read an article that said some bedlington terrier breeders used poodle blood to get a better coat for showing so there could be a few poodle blooded lurchers already :whistling: Quote Link to post
whin 463 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 A GIMMIK THE GUY WANTS TO RETIRE I GOT ASKED ONCE TO [bANNED TEXT] FOR C MW ABOUT HUNTING AND HERE AND THE USA NEVER DONE IT ,ITS A CENSORED MAGAZINE FULL STOP ,SAYS ARE LONG GONE WHEN WE CAN WRITE IN FREEDOM Quote Link to post
Bosun11 537 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 I've commented on this cross before but here it is again, the standard poodle in its native France is still used as a gundog but only in limited ammounts, like for instance the cumbler spaniel, find (import) the 'right' type and maybe you'll get a sevicable lurcher that'll catch you the odd bunny or two but i'd be very surprised if these became real 'when the chips are down', do or die lurchers! Now i ain't read the article but i'll bet Mr Ratcher has gone and used a KC redge Poodle with nothing to commend it as a 'working dog', all I see is £££££ and with him writing in the CMW, i'm sure he'll make a pretty penny as he has the voice to big 'em up and sell 'em, for over inflated prices 'because of all the effort in finding the dog , having the litter etc'. What will happen is, these mutts will inevitably find their way into the decent Lurcher gene pool and become another 'blot'!! I see this cross with nothing to add that your average working gun dog cross could not do, save hight. If anyone out there gets one, I for one would like to hear of its progress and would love to stand corrected in 18 months time! And as for Typp Ratcher, he is a tosser, who writes lame ass articles for a sub-standard 'working' dog mag.....! Don't belive the hype!! Quote Link to post
dean1 46 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 I went out one night about 14 years ago ,i was running my 3/4 greyhound x 1/4 alsation and my mate was running his first x greyhound x standard poodle ,we both had 3 runs each, the result was the alsation 29 itts caught three things. Now poodle could not catch any thing all night, the poodle wasn,t sharp enough or just poo. Quote Link to post
Leeview 791 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 Not defending TP but to get 1/8 its obviously 3/4 grey1/4 poodleXgreyhound so somewhere these have been bred as 1/2 X back to grey making these 3rd generationXs, anyone heard about these previous Xs? Y.I.S Leeview Quote Link to post
matt32 44 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 I've commented on this cross before but here it is again, the standard poodle in its native France is still used as a gundog but only in limited ammounts, like for instance the cumbler spaniel, find (import) the 'right' type and maybe you'll get a sevicable lurcher that'll catch you the odd bunny or two but i'd be very surprised if these became real 'when the chips are down', do or die lurchers!Now i ain't read the article but i'll bet Mr Ratcher has gone and used a KC redge Poodle with nothing to commend it as a 'working dog', all I see is £££££ and with him writing in the CMW, i'm sure he'll make a pretty penny as he has the voice to big 'em up and sell 'em, for over inflated prices 'because of all the effort in finding the dog , having the litter etc'. What will happen is, these mutts will inevitably find their way into the decent Lurcher gene pool and become another 'blot'!! I see this cross with nothing to add that your average working gun dog cross could not do, save hight. If anyone out there gets one, I for one would like to hear of its progress and would love to stand corrected in 18 months time! And as for Typp Ratcher, he is a tosser, who writes lame ass articles for a sub-standard 'working' dog mag.....! Don't belive the hype!! Quote Link to post
loopy2k9 0 Posted October 11, 2009 Report Share Posted October 11, 2009 someone should phone this man to see if he actually knows what he's talking about of wether he knows what he is talking about or if hes just a dirty chancer Quote Link to post
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.