A good dog or a great one in my humble opinion is one that when in the field exels as such that anyone who is with you is amazed at his guts stamina and strike rate will catch alive and retrieve what you want to eat,with the exeption of deer,will kill what you dont.Will mark without error,Would guard you and loved ones to the death,Will give you many a great memory of him when he is gone,a practically impossible dog to replace,thinking of you scoob