I used to be a devotee of the Muckboot Esk (I think, the one with the good tread) wellingtons. They were warm, they were heavy. But, they have two fatal flaws for the land I walk and hunt here. They split at the seams, expecially back around the heel, I think one split where the toes flex as well. They are rip very easily. one pair got a glancing blow from the deck of the sheep trailer as I was putting it in, went through the boot like a hot knife through butter. I think I had two or three pairs of them so not just giving out about one bad pair.
Now I'm on Dunlop Puroforts, the non safety