IMO I do think that any of the HPR (Hunt, Point, Retrieve) breeds are a little too involved for the first time or novice trainer. These breeds can be very head strong and stubborn. This combined with a strong hunting drive could be a recipe for disaster in novice hands. They also tend to be quite sensitive, and do not respond well to harsh handling! They will push even the more experienced handlers to their limit sometimes, and this can be disheartening. You are also limited to the number of trainers experienced with these breeds, should you need guidance at any point. Having said that, if you