well mate i've read all of this thread with people on your case for not giving the dog another chance and others clapping you for doing the right thing but what i want to know is did you really do the right thing and go up and chap the farmers door and let him know that your dog had killed his sheep like the responsible dog man you want us to believe you are or did you keep your mouth shut and slinky off the hills and away leaving the farmer on your prescious permisson wondering what the fecks happened here